AI

Dispute

How AI can help you analyze a statement of defense in a civil dispute

Follow a fictional dispute from a new statement of defense to source checking and drafting a submission in LexBox Workspace.

LexBox

Two people are reviewing documents at a conference table.


A new statement of defense can change what the dispute team needs to investigate. In this fictional example, we show how a lawyer can compare the defense with their own claim, follow up on sources in the case file, and draft a focused response using LexBox Workspace.

The Case in Brief

A supplier is claiming SEK 240,000 following the delivery and installation of office furnishings. The claim consists of SEK 160,000 for the original delivery and SEK 80,000 for additional work. In the statement of defense, the client confirms that the base delivery took place. The client disputes the payment claim for the add-on and states that part of the installation needs to be redone.

Four Documents to Check

C1, the order dated March 3, item 4. This specifies the price of SEK 160,000 for delivery and installation according to the original specification.

C2, invoice 117, lines 2 and 3. The base delivery is invoiced at SEK 160,000 and the additional work at SEK 80,000.

C3, the email thread from March 18. The client's project manager writes: "Go ahead with the extra cabinets so we can make it in time for the opening." The part of the thread included in the case file does not indicate a price.

D1, the inspection report from April 2, item 6. The report states that two doors are sticking. It does not indicate which invoice line they pertain to or what remediation would cost.

From Statement of Defense to Verifiable Questions

Issue in Dispute

Support in Case File

Lawyer's Check

Base delivery

Defense item 3, C1 and C2

Has any part of the payment claim been conceded?

Approval of the add-on

Defense item 5 and C3

What was agreed regarding price, and what authority did the project manager have?

Objection regarding installation

Defense item 7 and D1

Which part of the delivery and what amount are affected?

1. What is uncontested regarding the base delivery?

The statement of defense, item 3, confirms that the base delivery arrived. C1 and C2 show what work was ordered and invoiced. Check whether the client also concedes any part of the payment claim. The fact that the delivery is uncontested does not determine what the client has conceded regarding payment.

2. What does the email support regarding the add-on?

The statement of defense, item 5, states that the add-on lacked approval. C3 supports the assertion that the project manager asked the supplier to proceed. The case file needs to be supplemented to assess what was said about the price and what authority the project manager held.

3. What does the report show about the installation?

The statement of defense, item 7, refers to defects in the installation. D1 documents two sticking doors. Link this point to the correct part of the delivery and check whether the client has specified which amount is affected by the objection.

Example of a Focused Draft Response

"The supplier refers to the email of March 18, Exhibit C3, in which the client's project manager asked the supplier to proceed with the extra cabinets. The supplier will revert with supporting documentation for the invoiced amount and clarify which part of the work was covered by the add-on. The client is requested to specify which delivered items are referred to in the inspection report's remark and how the objection affects the disputed amount."

Ahead of the next review, the lawyer needs to examine C3 in its entirety, verify which additional works the invoice refers to, and ensure that every assertion in the draft is supported by the case file. This example illustrates a working method. The documents, amounts, and draft are fictional.

Read more about LexBox Workspace and how AI can help identify gaps in the evidence.

START YOUR NEXT MOVE

Ready to see your case clearly?Transform complex material into a vivid process graph and move forward with greater confidence.

LexBox applies the same structural framework to arbitration, adapted to arbitral rules, confidentiality, and procedure.

Copyright ©LexBox AB. All rights reserved.

LexBox applies the same structural framework to arbitration, adapted to arbitral rules, confidentiality, and procedure.

Copyright ©LexBox AB. All rights reserved.

LexBox applies the same structural framework to arbitration, adapted to arbitral rules, confidentiality, and procedure.

Copyright ©LexBox AB. All rights reserved.